The models developed for several important forest … • The effects of Toxorhynchites rutilus kairomones and chemical alarm cues on Aedes triseriatus were assessed in a two‐level factorial design manipulating nutrient level (low or high) and chemical cues of predation (present or absent). 2002) or with delayed reproduction (Frogner 1980), and either of these nonlethal effects may, regulate population size. 2000, Gimnig et al. 3. The population dynamics of fisheries is used by fisheries scientists to determine sustainable yields. 1991). Marten GG, Bordes ES, Nguyen M. Use of cyclopoid copepods for mosquito control. [PubMed: Rivière, F. Effects of two predators on community composition and biological control of. There is both, direct (Lounibos 1985, Washburn et al. Boundedness of a population can also be described statistically: in a regulated, ). These models have focused primarily on the population. This review suggests a need for better data on density dependent, Population dynamics is the portion of ecology that deals with the variation in time and space, of population size and density for one or more species (Begon et al. They also provide an example, of how following the dynamics of mosquito populations and their enemies could enhance the, effectiveness of biological control. We found that the latter may be sub-optimal when modelling Ae. How would this new growth rate influence the population size at time t = 20? This review suggests a need for better data on density dependent regulation of mosquito populations. 3) When during the life cycle does a particular biological control agent impose, Service (1985) reviewed the literature on mortality affecting immature mosquitoes and, concluded that overcrowding and density dependent mortality were often major factors, affecting populations of container breeding mosquitoes, including those in both natural and. Timothy D. Schowalter, in Insect Ecology (Second Edition), 2006. Journal of Vector Ecology 2002;2002;27:138–148. Density dependent population regulation among immature stages, has important implications for biological control of mosquito populations, primarily because it can. First, it presents density dependent population regulation, and its implications for, biological control of mosquito populations. AN ANIMAL POPULATION LAB TRY THIS POPULATION DYNAMICS OF DUCKWEED LAB FOR A LONG TERM PROJECT' '2017 World Population Data Sheet prb org August 12th, 2017 - The world population will reach 9 8 billion in 2050 up 31 percent from an estimated 7 5 billion now according to projections included in the 2017 World Population Data Sheet from the Population Reference Bureau PRB This … Service (1985) argued that added mortality imposed by a control agent should act after density, dependence has taken its toll on a target mosquito population. (1985) were control. Greater per‐capita population growth could therefore result from early mortality of larvae, meaning that the hydra effect, which predicts greater equilibrium population with, as opposed to without, extrinsic mortality, may be possible for these mosquitoes. However, metapopulation theory suggests that spatiotemporally uneven larvicide treatment can impede control effectiveness, as recolonization compensates for mortality within patches. We are seeking crowd funding through EXPERIMENT, the scientific crowd-funding website. These, characteristics also lead to the conclusion that specialist enemies like parasitoids are the ideal, biological control agent, and that generalist enemies are poor candidates for biological control, (Murdoch et al. Journal of Vector Ecology 2004;29:124–134. albopictus population dynamics. Set alert. (Diptera: Culicidae) on the Kenya Coast. © 2008-2020 ResearchGate GmbH. This scenario opens the way to an enriched entomological landscape with three container-breeding mosquitoes interacting and thus complicating the epidemiological status of vector-borne pathogens; Both predators tended to prefer second instar mosquito prey among surface area and water depth variations, whilst generally avoiding the largest (fourth instar) and smallest (first instar) prey instar stages. released from predation pressure due to climatic effects on predators. Understandings of these biotic factors is important for robust quantifications of natural enemy effects on target species, yet their combined influence lacks investigation. 1985), suggesting additive, mortality. 10 1.2 linkages between demographic change, urbanization and disaster risk A change in the human presence and scale of activities such as the one observed in the last four decades will necessarily have significant effects on the environment and ecosystems.This change in the scale of human presence translates into increasing exposure and … Insect Life Cycles: Genetics, evolution, and co-ordination. For organisms with complex life cycles, such as mosquitoes, different pressures are expected to act on communities due to behavioral and ecological partitioning of life stages. Insect Ecology. Iran’s Population Dynamics and Demographic Window of Opportunity In the second half of the twentieth century, Iran completed its demographic transition from high to low mortality and, with a time lag, from high to low fertility. protozoan and bacterial enemies that have been used in biological control. Ecology 1995;76:1242–1250. Hydrobiologia, Bradshaw WE, Holzapfel CM. View Population Dynamics Research Papers on for free. Results showed that the study area is widely suitable for Ae. A generic weather-driven model of mosquito population dynamics was applied to Rift Valley fever vector species in northern Senegal, with rainfall, temperature, and humidity as inputs. Moreover, the correlation coefficients at each lag between the water level and fish abundance identified by the CCF provided a mechanism to understand how the flow pulse influenced the dynamics of fish. Once common, prairies are now among the most threatened of ecosystems. 1998, Rey et al. Therefore, estimating coordination costs is an important step for most effectively applying metapopulation theory to strategies for managing outbreaks of mosquito-borne viral infections. The difficulties of controlling, mosquitoes that arise from strong density dependent limitation of mosquitoes in container, habitats (see above) may have contributed to some of these failures of control by, suggests that there is potential for control of mosquitoes using either specialist or generalist, enemies. ټ��;ߢ�_��0ꠑ���,��#d�b��� \��긋�L��u٥X���0�� Section 2 reviews theoretical and empirical literature on the effect of demographics on labor supply, savings, and economic growth and explores … HUMAN POPULATION GROWTH: A BRIEF HISTORY The human population has grown rapidly because of the expansion of agriculture and industrial production and lower death rates from improvements in hygiene and medicine. These preferences reflected predator:prey weight–length ratios, showing that relative sizes of predators and prey are important factors in prey selectivity. of an enemy are related to probability of successful control, which is discussed below. significance of temporal variation in female fecundity. 2. Life expectancy is the number of years that an average person can expect to live. be highly successful control agents precisely because they lack the characteristics identified in, investigations of classical biological control by parasitoids (monophagy, synchrony, rapid, population growth). There are costs to antipredator defenses and the strength of prey responses to cues of predation likely depends on both the perceived level of risk and food availability. Topics covered include single species models, Bifurcations, interacting populations that include predation. [PubMed: 9086702], Schreiber ET, Hallmon CF, Eskridge KM, Marten GG. Leyse KE, Lawler SP, Strange T. Effects of an alien fish. 1991, Nannini & Juliano 1998) and circumstantial, evidence for compensation or overcompensation in tree hole and human-made container, systems. rate remains constant (Frogner 1980). Field trials have established that mermithids in the genus. University Press of New, Murdoch WW, Briggs CJ. There are several areas within the field of population dynamics that overlap considerably with, other chapters in this volume. Florida Medical Entomology. There was a negligible effect of spatial and environmental factors on mosquito community structure, and temporal effects on mosquito abundances and distributions appear to be driven by changes in abundance of the dominant predator, perhaps because ICE are stronger than OCE due to larval habitat restriction, or because adult dispersal is not limited at the chosen spatial scales. [PubMed: 535875], Gimnig JE, Ombok M, Otieno S, Kaufman MG, Vulule JM, Walker ED. albopictus invasion dynamics. albopictus introduction in the study area was more likely to have happened in spring or summer, and that the derived population remained at low density for a long time. Empirical data that directly address the question of additive/compensating/. I then studied the types of cues used by these prey to gauge predation risk by examining prey responses to simple disturbances and to potential chemical cues associated with predation. We determined behavior of larvae in these environments, recording their positions (bottom, wall, leaf, top, or middle) and activities (browsing, filtering, resting, or thrashing) using instantaneous scan censuses. density dependent effects on mosquito populations (e.g., Renshaw et al. In: Kerfoot, WC. Oecologia. browsing on container and detritus surfaces. species some time in the future and is some intervention desirable to alter that expectation?). Females raised in the high nutrient and predator cue treatment blood fed sooner than did females from other combinations. Southwood TRE, Murdie G, Yasuno N, Tonn RJ, Reader PM. 1972, Service 1985, Léonard & Juliano 1995) it is also clear that for some mosquitoes, density dependent food shortage resulting from interspecific competition affects survivorship, (Juliano et al. Continuous Models of Population Growth: In general, mathematical models of population growth come in two flavors: … Sinauer Associates, Inc; Sunderland, MA: 1995. We also discussed the role and applications of these modelling approaches for linking the changes in environmental parameters and fish. Although the optimal methods are likely context‐dependent, broadly applicable strategies for mosquito control, such as how to distribute limited resources across a landscape in times of high epidemic risk, can mitigate (re)‐emerging outbreaks. Population Dynamics A game is solved for each population with constraints given by masses mp, which will vary dynamically. In: Lounibos, LP. A. albopictus spent significantly more time at leaf surfaces, whereas A. aegypti spent more time engaging in nonfeeding activities. PopulationDynamics 2. 1993, Lord 1998. Gleiser et al. Adult females select habitats for oviposition, and resulting offspring are confined to that habitat until reaching adult stages capable of flight; outside-container effects (OCE) (i.e., spatial factors) are thus expected to act more strongly on species distributions as a function of adult dispersal capability, which should be limited by geographic distances between sites. population has both the largest cohort of young people (age 24 and under) and the largest proportion of elderly in history. Modeling (Lord, Chapter #) is of course a prominent topic within. ephemeral pools. 2) When during the immature stages does density dependence act on a particular, target mosquito? 1999, Blanco Castro et al. high, suggesting strong interspecific competition in these largely predator-free habitats. Density also affects growth and development rates, resulting in smaller, adults with lower fecundity that would be the case for uncrowded individuals (Cochrane. Ecological Applications 2005;15:587–598. Student Worksheet (PDF) 314 KB. Reintroduction of the pathogen or toxin is. Thus, biological control in permanent ground water, habitats seems to have the highest likelihood of producing a satisfactory result. If so, what biological. In drought years, predator populations crashed, and remained low into the, following year. (Notostraca: Triopsidae), a biological control agent of mosquitoes. triseriatus in a laboratory experiment in which we monitored behavior of individual mosquitoes in two different food environment treatments: food suspended in the water column only and food attached to leaf surfaces only. Lounibos LP, Escher RL, Nishimura N, Juliano SA. Population Dynamics. 1990). In: May, RM., editor. albopictus population dynamics modelling; Low density yielded significant increases in adult size, adult longevity, and size‐dependent fecundity, and a decrease in development time. Though ecologists typically think of density, dependent death as the archetypical regulatory process, density dependent growth or, development rates (e.g., Frogner 1980, Kleckner et al. lead to compensatory or overcompensatory mortality due to additions of a biological control agent. Manriquesaide P, Ibanezbernal S, Delfingonzalez H, Tabla VP. He suggested that enemies that, attack late larval or pupal stages would therefore be most effective as biological control agents, and that killing eggs or early stage larvae would be less effective (Service 1985). Many pathogens associated with mosquitoes are indeed changing their ecology or modifying their geographical and biological distribution, being considered as invasive species. enemies resulting in unstable dynamics (Murdoch et al. These themes are used as the area where to understand different types of mathematical modeling and the possible meaning of qualitative agreement of modeling with data. Blackwell Science, Stav G, Blaustein L, Margalit Y. Most of these releases. Dynamics associated to each population are shown in (4). Fish, D. An analysis of adult size variation within natural mosquito populations. Unit 1.1 Population Dynamics What you need to know and be able to do: Tick off those you feel confident about: Describe and suggest reasons for the rapid increase in the world’s population in recent times, ‘the population explosion’. We used a field experiment in a mainland-island scenario to assess whether environmental, spatial, and temporal factors influence mosquito prey and predator distributions and abundances across spatial scales: within-site, between-site, and mainland-island. In contrast, in more stable or larger habitats, introduction of pathogens and, predators may be more likely to produce additive mortality and thus reduce production of adult, mosquitoes. Life-histories may be separated into groups of traits that covary and function together, generally relating to growth and development, reproduction, dormancy and migration (Tauber and Tauber 1981; Tauber et al. Introductions of tadpole shrimp (, pools have produced effects on mosquito populations that suggest additive mortality (Fry et, avoidance by ovipositing females of habitats with, demonstrated that nymphs of the dragon fly. 1978, Bradshaw & Holzapfel 1983, Focks & Sacket 1985, Mogi et al. • The goal of this study was to test the hypothesis that the costs of nonlethal trait‐mediated interactions impacting larvae can have carryover effects that alter life‐history traits, adult characteristics, and ultimately population dynamics. Biocontrol News and Information 2000;21:105N–116N. production of adult or pupal container-dwelling mosquitoes (e.g., Gerberg & Visser 1978, et al. 1997). albopictus adjust their antipredatory responses to be proportional to size-dependent risk of predation. [PubMed: Chase JM, Knight T. Drought-induced mosquito outbreaks in wetlands. Suitable for Post graduate students and beginning researchers in Mathematical Biology. Ecology 1994;75:271–287. Lounibos (1985) showed that pupation success of, In addition to these studies directly addressing patterns of predator-induced mortality, a number, of studies of container-dwelling predators indicate that presence of predators, either native or, introduced, reduce the numbers of prey mosquitoes in the system (e.g., Gerberg & Visser. Journal of the American Mosquito Control Association 1996;12:155–159. Specific objectives 1. sity are important for efforts to control vector mosquitoes via extrinsic mortality of larvae, including chemical larviciding, biological control, or transgenic control, because extrinsic mortality can alleviate those density effects, yielding adult populations that are as large, or larger than would be the case without control efforts (compensation or overcompensation). 1972, Hawley 1985a, b, Léonard & Juliano 1995, Frankino & Juliano 1999, Lounibos et al. success were additive (i.e., no significant interaction of predator and competitor treatments). Define the main components influencing population growth – … , a predatory mosquito larva. … depending on whether resource levels were high, moderate, or low, respectively. Science293 638-643 Su TY, Mulla MS. Introduction and establishment of tadpole shrimp, Triopsidae) in a date garden for biological control of mosquitoes in the Coachella Valley, southern, California. Download as PDF. The second component, dealing with causal processes, is important because it can provide a, general framework for strategies to control mosquitoes. Control of. Two possible scenarios can be hypothesised; partitioning of the spatial niche (geographical differentiation) or of the temporal niche (temporal differentiation), through both resource (larval stage; ... predation) it is possible that the number of survivors may be unaffected by, or increase with, increased mortality. 1999, Perez-Pacheco et al. These characteristics are direct outgrowth of, the aforementioned assumption: the key to success is that the introduced enemy and the target, pest reach a stable two-species equilibrium, with the target population’s equilibrium density, much lower than that attained in the absence of the enemy (Murdoch et al. LESSON 1 ORGANISM AND POPULATION CHARACTERISTICSOF POPULATION 1. For each mosquito in each food environment, we quantified the time allocated by larvae to one of four positions and to one of three activities. Section 2 reviews . Fourth-instar Ae. the aquatic community in aroid axils, with special reference to mosquiotes. (1985) and Murdoch &, desirable for biological control, and that often the ideal biological control effort results in, consists of both models of population dynamics of control by generalist predators, showing, that extinction of the target species is often the expected result, and empirical data showing, that such generalist predators can produce successful control (Murdoch et al. Our experiments suggest that differences in foraging behavior contribute to the competitive advantage of A. albopictus over A. aegypti that has been observed in North America. Young . have become threats to native fish, amphibians, and invertebrates (e.g., have provided convincing evidence that such a stable equilibrium is not always, population dynamics of the target species, including local extinction. Revista Do Instituto, in Wat Samphaya, Bangkok, Thailand. [PubMed: 9775616], Lounibos LP. Unique features of the book are: (1) an emphasis on \parameter free" phase plane analysis, (2) the usage of the epidemiological concept of an R 0 (or tness) to simplify parameter conditions, and (3) a strong … Does temperature, affect the outcome of larval competition between, Vector Ecology 2002;27:86–95. 2004). %�쏢 In order to, minimize redundancy with these other chapters, this one will not provide a comprehensive, review of mathematical models of vector populations, nor detailed case studies of effects of, particular pathogens or predators of vectors. Variable developmental period: intraspecific competition models with conditional age-. 2. 1991, Washburn 1995, Service 1985). This article is protected by copyright. They also fit very well most of the characteristics described above for, ideal biological control agents. Studies on the life budget of, Speight, MR.; Hunter, MD. ground water habitats with less evident density dependent effects and additive mortality. Biological control in theory and practice. prey. Oecologia 1983;57:239–256. Effects of, Cyclopidae) on mosquitoes that inhabit tires – influence of litter type, quality, and quantity. Journal of the American Mosquito Control Association, 10.2987/8756-971X(2007)23[265:PD]2.0.CO;2, Environmental modelling and spatial ecology with focus on invasive Aedes mosquitoes and emergent mosquito-borne pathogens, Effects of larval density on a natural population of Culex restuans (Diptera: Culicidae): no evidence of compensatory mortality: No compensatory mortality in Culex restuans, Inside-container effects drive mosquito community structure in Brazilian Atlantic forest, The demographic and life-history costs of fear: Trait-mediated effects of threat of predation on Aedes triseriatus, Modelling spatial and temporal dynamics of two small mud carp species in the Tonle Sap flood-pulse ecosystem, Coordination among neighbors improves the efficacy of Zika control despite economic costs, Prey size and predator density modify impacts by natural enemies towards mosquitoes, Prey preferences of notonectids towards larval mosquitoes across prey ontogeny and search area, Spatial Modeling of Mosquito Vectors for Rift Valley Fever Virus in Northern Senegal: Integrating Satellite-Derived Meteorological Estimates in Population Dynamics Models, (Meta)population dynamics determine effective spatial distributions of mosquito‐borne disease control. agents. Considering the admittedly limited literature, on dynamics associated with stable biological control systems, it appears that among mosquito, enemies, only mermithid nematodes fit the mold of the specialist parasitoids widely used in, biological control. A deme is a smaller unit of a population found in a localized area. 2005), demonstrating the ability of, these parasitic nematodes to reduce mosquito populations. 1994, et al. Finally it is also possible that an additional source of mortality may be, added source of mortality has the intuitive effect of increasing observed total mortality, (Washburn et al. Alan Hastings, in Encyclopedia of Biodiversity (Second Edition), 2013. Thus, for ephemeral ground water habitats, limited data suggest that additive, mortality may be common, and prospects for biological control may be better than for container, Biological control in permanent ground water habitats, In these habitats, consideration of density dependent effects on mosquito population dynamics, leads to the expectation that additive mortality should be prevalent, and biological control, efforts should be more likely to succeed. Gambusia affinis reduced the abundance of the pest Culex tarsalis in a rice field in San Joaquin Valley, California. 1996, Manriquesade et al. Hassell, MP. �8X����IP�)���$G���w]m.��^Z���>���2`���Zx}�}�*��uW��D]t�+� These findings support the hypothesis that the recent Ae. Journal of the American Mosquito Control Association, Washburn JO, Mercer DR, Anderson JR. Regulatory role of parasites: Impact on host population shifts, with resource availability. In: Lounibos, LP. We used mathematical simulations to examine how the spatial distribution of larval mosquito control affects the size of disease outbreaks, and how mosquito metapopulation dynamics and demography might impact the efficacy of different spatial distributions of control. Laboratory; Vero Beach FL: 1985. p. 185-201. Although intraspecific, competition and density dependent mortality have received the most attention (Southwood et. • Fear of predation can substantially alter prey life‐history traits and behavior, which can cascade into dramatic population, community, and ecosystem effects. Ecology: Individuals, Populations and Communities. Annals of the Entomological Society of America. Density-dependent development, Entomology 2002;39:162–172. However, data documenting the, There are instances in which mosquitofish fail to produce reductions of numbers of adults, (Blaustein 1992) and in some cases introduction of mosquitofish has resulted in, abundances of mosquitoes (reviewed by Bence 1988). Behavioral Ecology 2002;13:301–311. Succession, distribution, overcrowding and predation in. Nevertheless, consideration of population dynamics of generalist predators. A. In: Lounibos, LP. LESSON 1 ORGANISM AND POPULATION Organism Is a single, living individual, either plant or animal. TEXT ID f53a5552 Online PDF Ebook Epub Library population dynamics what factors influence human population growth trends most strongly and how does population growth or decline impact the environment does urbanization threaten our quality of life or offer a pathway to better living conditions what are the social implications of an aging world population discover how demographers approach … Interactions between multiple predators can modify prey risk and profoundly alter ecological community dynamics. (1) A 3-year field study of larval populations of Aedes sierrensis, a common North American tree-hole mosquito, produced no evidence for density-dependent larval mortality, but revealed that pupal weight of females was inversely correlated with larval density. Theoretical Ecology: principles. This article is protected by copyright. Such effects of den, This is a project on which I collaborate with team leader Vickie Borowicz. Effect of introduced crayfish and mosquitofish on California newts. albopictus life cycle durations. [PubMed: 8827587], Santamarina Mijares A, Perez-Pacheco R. Reduction of mosquito larval densities in natural sites after, Entomology 1997;34:1–4. \Niche '' to justify its existence [ PubMed: 11107892 ], Schreiber et, Hallmon,... Among neighbors can improve management of mosquito-borne epidemics under many, but in contrast to temporary, wetlands, populations..., Brown MD, Hendrikz JK, Greenwood JG, Kay BH than Gp a relatively short.! To live or actual increases in adult production, stability and field experiments in.... Grant R01 AI-44793 significant shift in foraging activity toward leaves when leaves were available organisms over time ) and,! &,, Schreiber et, Hallmon CF, Eskridge KM, GG! Estimated per‐capita population growth rate was significantly greater in the target ORGANISM potential competitors but show a greater concentration foraging. Tello Granados R, Mendoza I, Urrutia J, Montes-Belmont R, Rodriguez-Hernandez C Lara-Reyna... Sunderland, MA: 1995 effort at the top of a population can also described... Experts in,, Schreiber et, Hallmon CF, Eskridge KM Marten! Be proportional to size-dependent risk of predation by cyclopoid copepods for mosquito larvae that develop in permanent ground water,. Collaborate with team leader Vickie borowicz a drought, mosquito, Brown,! Last 25 years, predator populations were always low and populations of non-mosquito competitors uniformly... Than did females from other combinations species and ecosystem management plants can reduce aggressive species but effects. ; Vero Beach, FL: 1985. p. 95-119, Stiling p. how risky biological! Regulation can also be defined as boundedness of the eco-system evident density dependent mortality have received the most (. Demographic surveillance, coordination improves disease outcomes, even when they are rare ) ( Huffaker & 1976. S, Menéndez Z, Lounibos LP, Byer G. Laboratory and predicted behaviour... Habitats, and either of these nonlethal effects may, regulate population size population! Alter that expectation? ) species inhabiting permanent habitats were less variable, and on mosquito larvae must consider the. Container habitats indicate strong the sudden … Download as PDF a, framework. The abundance of microorganisms in mosquito larvae that develop in permanent ground water seems... Species, which spent more time thrashing below the surface, Blaustein L Margalit... Female size and fecundity, and quantity principles of population: a collective group of organisms of the population... This conclusion was also, studies of reproduction are generally associated with life-cycles. In environmental parameters and fish of lower density on adult Longevity, and habitat drying and... Understanding the relative importance of … this book is an important tool for mitigating outbreaks human modification natural... Tabla VP, M. ; Horio, M. ; Miyagi, I. ; Cabrera,.! Was due to insects, Murdoch et al academic Press ; New York, NY:.... Hunter, MD wolves were removed from the yellowstone area, the book needs a novel \niche '' justify! & Perez-Pacheco 1997, Peng et al a side effect of globalisation human... Depends on both costs and different surveillance methods jointly influence the effectiveness of larval, Entomology 2004 97:194–201! These findings support the hypothesis that the study of population dynamics that may be useful or conceptually for! Are seeking crowd funding through EXPERIMENT, the scientific crowd-funding website 77:2001– Nannini. Compensatory or overcompensatory mortality, and on mosquito populations ( e.g., the target ORGANISM empirical Examples used Murdoch! ( 1 ) the prevalence of the target mosquitoes ( Ng: fourth instar ; Gp: instar. 5 explores Ae Kenya Coast is potentially, very important for population dynamics pdf control those... Tree hole epidemics of mosquito‐borne dengue and Zika viruses demonstrate the urgent need for data... In drought years, predator populations were always high of litter type, quality and..., very important for biological, control and decoupling from mosquito prey in a relatively time! Treehole ecosystem of two predators on community composition and biological distribution, being considered as invasive.! Population density of, Kesavaraju b, population dynamics pdf 1985, Murdoch 1994 ) take advantage of New opportunities by. And establishment of the American mosquito control ( reviewed by Collins & Blackwell 2000 ) and, resource! Rate, death rate and mechanism of density‐dependent regulation of mosquito, populations ( e.g., et... Exploit human movements to disperse unstable biological control as both a conceptual area and as a factor... On percentage survivorship pitcher-plant mosquito, populations and so render mortality additive methods jointly influence the effectiveness of larval Entomology. Those habitats most of the pest Culex tarsalis in a relatively short time urban with... Efforts using, have also yielded variable results ( reviewed by Murdoch et al factors also determined whether distributions. Agudelo-Silva F, Spielman A. Paradoxical effects of the same species living in the pitcher-plant,..., JR. ; Frank, JH., editors three species modify their behavior in similar ways in these predator-free. Predation rates of individual predatory insects and zooplankton earlier when exposed to predation,!